If you click a link on this page and make a purchase, we may receive a small commission at no extra cost to you.
Looking for the perfect glasses for the Old Fashioned cocktail that are sure to impress and elevate your drinking experience? You’re in the right place.
As a bartender with over a decade of experience, I’ve crafted (and drank) my fair share of Old Fashioneds, so I’m well aware of which glasses work best for this cocktail.
This minimalist yet potent drink—typically a careful concoction of whiskey, bitters, sugar, and a splash of water deserves to be served in the finest glassware that complements its rich heritage and complexity.
The perfect glass is more than just a vessel, it’s an extension of the drink itself. It enhances the visual appeal, intensifies the aroma, and amplifies the overall drinking experience. So, I’ve rounded up the 8 best glasses for Old Fashioned that perfectly fit the bill.
Each piece in our curated list encapsulates the right blend of style, functionality, quality, and that special something to accentuate the charm of your Old Fashioned.
From the traditional heavy-bottomed tumbler to chic and modern interpretations, we’ve got a variety that will cater to every preference.
Whether you’re an experienced mixologist in search of that perfect glass, a cocktail aficionado curating your home bar, or a party host keen on impressing your guests, this guide is your ticket to serving the Old Fashioned with the class it deserves.
So let’s get into it…
$16.99 ($4.25 / Count)
$19.89 ($4.97 / Count)
$59.95 ($29.98 / Count)
1. Hemswell Crystal Whiskey Glass For Old Fashioned
Step into a world of elegance and sophistication with Hemswell’s Crystal Whiskey Tumblers. Encased in an exquisite presentation box, these tumblers are not just drinking vessels—they are a statement.
If it’s high-quality you’re after, these are the glasses for you! I found myself instantly drawn to their hefty weight and the comfort they offered in my hand, a testament to their solid construction.
With a 10-ounce capacity, they hit the sweet spot—large enough for my favorite Old Fashioned with room for a luxuriously large ice cube, yet not so voluminous as to dwarf the cocktail.
Crafted from lead-free crystal, these tumblers are as transparent as they come, offering a lucidity that takes these glasses to the e next level.
This clarity truly highlighted the deep, golden hues of my whiskey, lending an aesthetic appeal that couldn’t be ignored.
Throughout my use of these glasses, I appreciated how the thick base kept my drink cool, a feature that any mixologist would approve of.
Yet, every rose has its thorns. On one hand, where the glass’s brilliance was a visual treat, it also meant fingerprints became quite noticeable. A minor inconvenience, but worth noting for those who lean towards perfection.
Overall, Hemswell’s Crystal Whiskey Tumblers are a fantastic addition to any bar. Their sophisticated design, premium feel, and optimal size make them the top choice for serving an Old Fashioned.
- Lead-free crystal offers brilliant clarity.
- The optimal size for an Old Fashioned.
- Comes in an elegant presentation box.
- Crystal clarity makes fingerprints noticeable.
2. Godinger Old Fashioned Whiskey Glass
Now let’s talk about an absolute stunner: the Godinger Old Fashioned Whiskey Glasses. These were an instant standout, not just for their aesthetics, but also for their impressive functionality.
A generous capacity of 11 ounces means they can effortlessly house an Old Fashioned, ice, and garnish without compromising on the presentation or dilution rate.
Crafted with high-quality crystal, these glasses convey a sense of luxury. In my hand, I could feel the weightiness that signified substance and quality, yet they were not overly heavy to the point of being cumbersome.
Each sip from this glass turned out to be a delightful experience, something that every cocktail aficionado would appreciate.
Unique to these glasses is the diamond-like detailing. To me, this feature wasn’t just visually appealing—it also provided a superior grip, reducing the chances of an unfortunate mishap. And let’s be honest, we’ve all had those moments of “butterfingers” after a few drinks!
Despite their ornate design, these Godinger glasses are surprisingly versatile. I found them as much at home with a casual gathering as with a formal dinner, making them a fantastic addition to any glassware collection.
One caveat to mention: these glasses are hand-wash only. This aspect can be a bit of a chore, especially after hosting a big gathering. But given their undeniable charm and performance, I would say the extra effort is definitely worth it.
Compared to the Hemswell Crystal Whiskey Tumblers, the Godinger glasses offer a more ornate, eye-catching design. If you’re someone who values aesthetics as much as function, Godinger should be your pick.
- Unique, diamond-like detailing adds visual appeal and grip.
- Substantial capacity of 11 ounces.
- High-quality crystal gives a premium feel.
- Requires hand-washing, which can be inconvenient.
3. OPAYLY Rocks Whiskey Glasses
Meet the OPAYLY Old Fashioned Tumblers—a no-frills, straightforward choice for any whiskey enthusiast.
When first holding these tumblers, what struck me was their simplicity, and I say this in the best way possible. With a classic, clean-cut design, they appeared unpretentious and inviting, a perfect canvas for my Old Fashioned.
With an 11-ounce capacity, these glasses comfortably accommodate a standard Old Fashioned, a large ice cube, and even some garnish, if you like that extra flair. Each pour in these glasses felt like I was paying homage to the timeless cocktail tradition.
Unlike the Godinger and Hemswell glasses, OPAYLY chose a minimalist approach, which appealed to my utilitarian side. On occasion, it’s quite refreshing to let the drink be the star, and these glasses do just that.
In my hand, these tumblers had a solid feel—neither too heavy nor too light. This optimal balance added comfort to my drinking experience which was quite pleasant.
The thick base provided excellent stability, an attribute every seasoned bartender can get behind.
On a less positive note, these glasses lacked a certain visual appeal. Though clean and simple, they didn’t carry the wow factor the Godinger glasses did with their diamond-like detailing.
However, I also understand that this comes down to personal preference. If you value function over form, these glasses might just be your perfect match.
- Clean, simple design puts the focus on the drink.
- 11-ounce capacity is perfect for an Old Fashioned.
- Solid and comfortable in hand.
- Lacks the visual appeal of some more ornate alternatives.
4. Aoeoe Whiskey Glasses
Here’s a glass that’s more than meets the eye: the Aoeoe Old Fashioned Whiskey Glasses. Initially, their charm lies in the striking modern design—a departure from the traditional style of the OPAYLY tumblers.
However, as I delved deeper, I discovered they were not just about aesthetics but also boasted functional advantages.
These glasses come with a unique twisted design that’s not only visually enticing but also adds a tactile experience.
As I cradled the glass in my hand, the twisted design provided a sturdy grip, assuring me of secure handling despite the smooth surface.
Capable of holding 10 ounces, these glasses are a perfect vessel for a well-crafted Old Fashioned. They allow ample room for the cocktail and a generous ice cube, while ensuring the drink’s flavors are not drowned out.
Now, let’s talk about the material. Crafted from premium lead-free crystal, these glasses offer the brilliance and transparency you’d expect from high-end glassware.
In my experience, this enhanced the visual appeal of my drink, adding to the overall cocktail experience.
However, there’s always room for improvement. My only minor gripe with these glasses was the narrower base. Compared to the Hemswell and OPAYLY glasses, the Aoeoe ones felt a bit less stable, especially on slick surfaces.
When it comes to style, these Aoeoe glasses are in a league of their own. Their contemporary design sets them apart from the classic appeal of the Hemswell and Godinger glasses, making them a standout pick for those who enjoy modern aesthetics.
- Unique, twisted design adds visual appeal and grip.
- Lead-free crystal offers brilliant clarity.
- Perfect 10-ounce capacity for an Old Fashioned.
- Narrower base can potentially make them less stable on slick surfaces.
5. JBHO Hand Blown Crystal Double Old Fashioned Glasses
Next up in the lineup is the JBHO Hand Blown Crystal Double Old Fashioned Glasses. At first glance, I was drawn to the simple elegance of their design—a beautiful harmony of form and function that appealed to my minimalist preferences.
When I first picked up these glasses, I was pleasantly surprised by their substantial feel, indicative of their hand-blown construction. They had a satisfying weight that communicated quality and durability.
Holding a comfortable 12 ounces, these glasses provide enough room for an Old Fashioned, ice, and garnish while preventing overfilling.
One thing I particularly admired about these glasses was their versatility. Their modern design and simple lines mean they can seamlessly transition from a casual gathering to a more formal setting, making them a valuable addition to any glassware collection.
Despite their relatively simple design, these glasses didn’t sacrifice aesthetics. Their premium crystal composition lent a brilliant clarity that made my whiskey look as good as it tasted.
Comparing them to the Aoeoe glasses, while they lack the unique twisted design, they make up for it with their understated elegance and superior hand feel.
For those who appreciate the nuanced art of cocktail making, these JBHO glasses provide a tasteful canvas to showcase their skills.
One potential drawback of these glasses is their larger size, which might not appeal to those who prefer more compact glassware. But, for those who enjoy a generously-sized Old Fashioned, like myself, these glasses hit the spot.
- Hand-blown construction offers a substantial feel and durability.
- Versatile design suitable for various settings.
- Brilliant clarity enhances visual appeal.
- Larger size might not appeal to everyone.
6. Veecom Whiskey Glass
Adding a hint of intrigue to our list is the Veecom Crystal Old Fashioned Whiskey Glasses. Their angular, geometric design immediately caught my eye, setting them apart from the more traditionally-styled options like the JBHO and Hemswell glasses.
Cradling one of these glasses, I was struck by the tactile experience. The geometric design wasn’t merely an aesthetic feature—it offered a unique, comfortable grip.
This thoughtful detail was a standout during my experience with these glasses, offering a reassuring hold even with wet hands.
With a capacity of 10 ounces, these glasses strike an ideal balance, holding enough to craft a perfect Old Fashioned without running the risk of overfilling. Their thick base lends a pleasing heft, further enhancing the feeling of quality.
The Veecom glasses are fashioned from premium lead-free crystal. This quality shone through, offering brilliant clarity that allowed my Old Fashioned to be the star of the show, elevating my drinking experience.
A small criticism I had was the sharper edges of the glass. While it didn’t interfere with the drinking experience, it might not suit everyone’s preferences, particularly if you like the smooth lines of glasses like the Aoeoe or Godinger.
In comparison with other glasses on the list, the Veecom glasses stand out with their unique geometric design. If you’re looking to break away from traditional glassware and enjoy a bit of modern flair, these glasses offer a compelling choice.
In essence, the Veecom Crystal Old Fashioned Whiskey Glasses offer a unique blend of function and form. They deliver on the basics—capacity, quality, and comfort—while providing a dash of modern style that truly sets them apart.
- Geometric design adds a unique modern flair and provides a comfortable grip.
- 10-ounce capacity is ideal for an Old Fashioned.
- High-quality lead-free crystal offers brilliant clarity.
- Angular design with sharper edges may not be to everyone’s liking.
7. Farielyn-X 10 OZ Scotch Glasses
Next on the list is the Mofado Crystal Whiskey Glasses. These glasses command respect with their substantial, chunky design, a far cry from the intricate details of the Veecom glasses or the slender elegance of the Aoeoe set.
Each Mofado glass holds an impressive 12 ounces, with plenty of room for a lavish Old Fashioned, complete with a sizable ice cube and garnish.
Holding one of these glasses was quite an experience; they had a certain heft to them that made each sip of my Old Fashioned feel like a special occasion.
Their clear, lead-free crystal construction enhances the visual experience, adding to the allure of your cocktail. For me, the thick-walled design and the weightiness of the glasses lend an air of sophistication and luxury.
But let’s not overlook functionality. These glasses have a thick, sturdy base, lending them a steadiness that surpassed the others on this list. This means less risk of spills, especially if you’re hosting a lively gathering.
However, their substantial size and weight might not be to everyone’s liking. If you prefer lighter, more delicate glassware, such as the Godinger or the Hemswell, the Mofado glasses might feel a bit overbearing.
In comparison to the other glasses, the Mofado set stands out for its heft and size, embodying a bold, statement-making style. If you appreciate boldness and gravitas in your barware, these glasses would be a worthy addition to your collection.
The Mofado Crystal Whiskey Glasses encapsulate a bold and luxurious drinking experience. Their impressive capacity, hefty construction, and beautiful crystal clarity make them a fantastic choice for the discerning Old Fashioned connoisseur.
- Hefty, substantial design adds a luxurious touch.
- Large 12-ounce capacity allows for a generous Old Fashioned.
- Sturdy base offers great stability.
- Substantial size and weight might not be ideal for those who prefer lighter glassware.
8. Gencywe Crystal Whiskey Glasses
Capping off our roundup is the Gencywe Old Fashioned Whiskey Glasses. With their modern take on a classic design, these glasses impressed me as a fantastic addition to any barware collection.
Picking up one of these glasses, I immediately noticed its sleek design and comfortable feel in the hand.
Made from durable, lead-free crystal, the glasses strike a balance between heft and manageability, neither too light nor too weighty, a mid-point between the substantial Mofado glasses and the more delicate Hemswell ones.
These Gencywe glasses hold a solid 11 ounces, ensuring there’s plenty of room for an ample Old Fashioned, complete with a chunky ice cube and a swirl of orange peel.
The clear crystal allowed the hues of my whiskey to shine through, adding a visual delight to the overall drinking experience.
One of the standout features of these glasses is their wide, stable base—a feature shared with the Mofado glasses. This provides a sense of security, even in the midst of lively social gatherings.
However, I found that the streamlined design, while stylish, might lack the charm of the more uniquely crafted glasses like the Veecom or Aoeoe sets. That said, if you prefer timeless style over ornate detailing, these glasses will not disappoint.
These glasses might not command the immediate attention of the Veecom or Mofado sets, but their understated elegance and functional design are certainly commendable.
- Sleek, timeless design suits any occasion.
- Comfortable capacity for a hearty Old Fashioned.
- Durable, lead-free crystal construction.
- The simplistic design may lack the appeal of more uniquely crafted glasses.
What To Look For In An Old Fashioned Glass
When it comes to choosing an Old Fashioned glass, there are several factors to consider. The Old Fashioned, a classic cocktail known for its simplicity and elegance, should be served in a glass that matches these qualities.
Here are some elements to look for:
The visual appeal of the glass can elevate the drinking experience. The glass should complement the drink’s appearance, color, and garnishes. A transparent glass is typically preferred to showcase the color of the whiskey and the garnish.
>> Read more: 7 BEST Whiskey Smoker Kits
An Old Fashioned glass should be large enough to accommodate the drink, ice (typically a large cube or sphere), and any garnishes, while leaving some room at the top. The volume is usually between 6 to 10 ounces.
>> Read more: 6 BEST Cognac Glasses For Home Bars
The classic Old Fashioned glass, also known as a lowball or rocks glass, is short with a wide brim. This allows for a good view of the cocktail, easy access for muddling ingredients, and space for the nose to take in the aroma.
>> Read more: 12 MUST Have Home Bar Accessories
A good Old Fashioned glass often has a solid, weighty feel. A thick base not only provides stability and a nice heft, but also helps keep the drink cool.
>> Read more: 6 BEST Whiskey Decanters For Home Bars
The quality of the glass material is important. It should be durable and able to withstand the thermal shock of ice. Lead-free crystal is a popular choice for its brilliance, clarity, and sound, but a good quality glass can also do the trick.
>> Read more: 8 BEST Ice Buckets To Keep Beverages Cool
The glass should feel comfortable to hold. Consider its weight distribution and whether it has a comfortable grip.
>> Read more: 7 BEST Shot Glasses For Home Bars
This might not be a dealbreaker, but a dishwasher-safe glass can make cleanup much easier, especially when hosting.
>> Read more: 6 BEST Glass Washers For Bars
What glass is best for an old-fashioned?
The best glass for an Old Fashioned is the lowball or rocks glass. Its design is tailored to the drink’s needs, boasting a wide brim and a thick, sturdy base.
The wide brim simplifies the muddling process of ingredients directly in the glass, and also accommodates a large ice cube or sphere. The thick base provides stability and a pleasant weightiness to the glass.
This glass’s compact size, typically between 6 to 10 ounces, is perfect for the typically short Old Fashioned cocktail, allowing the flavors and aromas to be savored without dilution over time.
Does the glass matter for an old-fashioned?
Absolutely, the glass does matter when serving an Old Fashioned. The traditional rocks glass, with its short, wide shape, facilitates muddling and aroma release, accommodates large ice cubes, and enhances the drink’s presentation. Using the right glassware elevates the overall experience of this classic cocktail.
Are whiskey glasses and old-fashioned glasses the same?
Yes, the terms “whiskey glasses” and “Old Fashioned glasses” are often used interchangeably. They both typically refer to a short tumbler glass, also known as a lowball or rocks glass.
This type of glass is favored for whiskey-based cocktails, like the Old Fashioned, due to its wide brim and sturdy base which allow for the easy muddling of ingredients and slow dilution of ice.
However, not all whiskey glasses are Old Fashioned glasses, as whiskey can also be served in other types of glasses such as the taller highball glass or the tulip-shaped Glencairn glass, which are not suitable for Old Fashioned cocktails.
What size is an old-fashioned glass?
An Old Fashioned glass typically has a capacity ranging from 6 to 10 ounces (180 to 300 milliliters). This size comfortably accommodates the volume of the cocktail, ice (usually a large cube or sphere), and any garnishes, while still leaving some room at the top.
The size is also well-suited to the traditionally “short” or undiluted nature of the Old Fashioned cocktail.
And there you have it. Eight of the finest Old Fashioned glasses that money can buy, meticulously reviewed and compared to bring you nothing but the best.
Each one of these glasses for Old Fashioned brings something unique to the table, offering an exquisite balance of style, quality, functionality, and individuality to enhance the savoring of this timeless cocktail.
So the next time you muddle sugar and bitters, spin that stirring spoon, or clink a cherry in an Old Fashioned, remember the power the right glass holds.
I hope this post has helped guide you in finding the right glass for you. Here’s to raising the bar of cocktail sophistication, one Old Fashioned at a time.
Catch you in the next one!