7 BEST Ice Molds For Bartenders [Buyers Guide]

If you click a link on this page and make a purchase, we may receive a small commission at no extra cost to you.

When it comes to creating drinks, the devil is in the details. From the choice of spirits to the garnish that graces the rim, every element plays a pivotal role in crafting the perfect cocktail.

But there’s one unsung hero that often goes unnoticed, yet can make or break the aesthetics and taste of your drink: ice.

Gone are the days when a simple cube would suffice. Today, ice molds have become an essential tool in the bartender’s arsenal, offering a number of shapes and sizes to complement every concoction.

Whether you’re a professional mixologist or a home bartender looking to impress your guests, the right ice mold can elevate your cocktail game to new heights.

That’s why I’ve scoured far and wide to source and test the best ice molds on the market to bring you only the finest options on the market.

So if it’s an ice mold you’re looking for, stick around as you’re in the right place!

Let’s get into it…

10/14/2023 05:30 pm GMT

1. ROTTAY Ice Cube Trays (Set of 2)

As a career bartender, I’ve always believed that the little details make the biggest difference.

And when it comes to crafting the perfect drink, ice is no small detail. First on our list is the ROTTAY Ice Cube Trays, a set that’s quickly become a staple in my arsenal.

From a user’s perspective, these trays are a dream. With one tray dedicated to sphere ice balls and the other to large square cubes, it’s evident that ROTTAY understands the diverse needs of bartenders.

Spherical ice is perfect for that whiskey on the rocks, ensuring minimal dilution, while the large square cubes are my go-to for cocktails, providing a consistent chill.

Now, let’s talk design. These trays come with lids, a feature I didn’t know I needed until I tried them.

No more freezer odors seeping into the ice! Plus, being made of durable silicone, releasing the ice is a breeze. No more tapping, twisting, or broken cubes.

Comparing them to other trays I’ve used, ROTTAY stands out in terms of versatility and ease of use.

While I do enjoy the functionality, I did find that the trays take a bit longer to freeze than some of my other molds. But given the size and quality of the ice produced, it’s a trade-off I’m willing to make.

Pros:

• Versatile with both sphere and square molds.
• Lids prevent odor contamination.
• Durable silicone ensures easy ice release.

Cons:

• Takes slightly longer to freeze compared to some other molds.

2. Bella Amazing Premium Ice Ball Molds (6-Pack)

During my time conducting this guide, I’ve come to appreciate the art of ice, more than before. It’s not just about cooling your drink; it’s about enhancing the entire experience.

And with the Bella Amazing Ice Ball Molds, that experience is taken to a whole new level.

From my first use, I was sold. These molds produce a consistent 2.5-inch ice sphere, which is the ideal size for most of my whiskey glasses.

For those unfamiliar with the magic of spherical ice, its shape allows for slower melting. This means your whiskey or bourbon remains undiluted for longer, preserving those intricate flavors we all cherish.

Crafted from BPA-free materials, there’s peace of mind knowing that safety isn’t compromised. And while I’ve tried numerous ice molds over the years, these stand out for their sheer simplicity.

No fancy mechanisms, just a straightforward design that works every time.

However, it’s not all sunshine and rainbows. While these molds are perfect for whiskey and bourbon, they might not be as versatile for those looking to craft diverse cocktails. But for a whiskey aficionado like me, they’re spot on.

When compared to other ice molds on the market, Bella Amazing’s commitment to quality is evident. They’ve stuck to what they know best, and it shows.

And while I haven’t used their previous versions, fellow bartenders have mentioned a noticeable improvement in the mold’s durability over time.

A strong choice for those looking for ice molds specifically for whiskey and bourbon.

Pros:

• Perfect size for whiskey glasses.
• BPA-free material ensures safety.
• Simple, effective design.

Cons:

• Not as versatile for diverse cocktails.

3. Samuelworld Large Silicone Premium Ice Trays

Behind every great bartender is a collection of tools that elevate their craft, and ice molds are no exception. Samuelworld’s Large Silicone Premium Ice Trays have quickly become a favorite in my toolkit, and here’s why.

Firstly, this 2-pack combo is great for versatility. With one tray dedicated to 2-inch big cubes and the other to 2.5-inch spheres, it’s evident that Samuelworld has catered to the diverse needs of drink enthusiasts.

Whether I’m crafting an Old Fashioned or serving up a neat pour of single malt, these molds have me covered.

Crafted from BPA-free silicone, these trays don’t just talk the talk; they walk the walk. Safety is paramount, especially when it comes to consumables, and knowing that these molds are free from harmful chemicals puts my mind at ease.

Plus, the gray hue adds a touch of sophistication that I, admittedly, am a sucker for.

Now, let’s talk functionality. Silicone molds are known for their flexibility, but Samuelworld takes it a notch higher.

Ice release is a breeze, eliminating the all-too-familiar struggle of chipping away at stubborn cubes or spheres.

But, I did find that the cube tray, given its size, requires a tad more freezing time to achieve that perfect solidity.

For those looking to gift a fellow bartender or drink enthusiast, this set is a winner. Its sleek design, combined with its dual functionality, makes it a standout choice.

If you’re not sure which ice molds to choose from this list, go with these. They’re our top pick and the best overall ice mold for almost all bartenders.

Pros:

• Dual molds for varied drink preferences.
• BPA-free silicone ensures safety and easy release.
• The sleek gray design adds a touch of elegance.

Cons:

• The Cube tray requires a slightly longer freezing time.

4. Tovolo Sphere Ice Molds – Set of 2

Not every tool needs to be flashy or extravagant. Sometimes, it’s the straightforward, no-frills options that get the job done best.

Enter the Tovolo Sphere Ice Molds, a set that’s as uncomplicated as it is effective.

Right off the bat, these molds won’t break the bank. They’re a more affordable option, making them perfect for those just starting their bartending journey or anyone looking for reliable functionality without the hefty price tag.

But don’t let the cost fool you; these molds deliver where it counts.

Each set comes with two molds, producing consistently sized ice spheres. In my experience, spherical ice is a game-changer, especially for drinks that deserve a slow melt and minimal dilution.

Whether it’s a smoky bourbon or a complex cocktail, these spheres ensure that every sip is as intended.

Made from sturdy plastic, the molds hold up well over time. While they might not have the flexibility of silicone counterparts, with a bit of patience and a gentle tap, the ice releases without much fuss.

One minor gripe I have is the occasional air bubble in the ice, but given the price point, it’s a trade-off I’m willing to accept.

But for bartenders on a budget, the Tovolo Sphere Ice Molds are a solid choice. They’re proof that you don’t need to splurge to serve up a chilled, delightful drink.

Pros:

• Affordable without compromising on essential functionality.
• Produces consistent ice spheres.
• Durable plastic construction.

Cons:

• Lacks the flexibility of silicone molds.
• Occasional air bubbles in the ice.

5. TINANA Crystal Clear Ice Ball Maker

In bartending, the difference between a good drink and a great one often lies in the details. And when it comes to ice, clarity is king.

TINANA’s Crystal Clear Ice Ball Maker is a testament to this, bringing a touch of elegance and precision to every glass.

What immediately stands out with this ice ball maker is its promise of crystal clear ice. And let me tell you, it delivers.

Each use results in 2.5” round spheres that are as clear as they are captivating. This isn’t just about aesthetics; clear ice melts more uniformly, ensuring a consistent chill without rapid dilution.

With a 4-cavity design, this mold is perfect for preparing multiple drinks simultaneously, a feature I’ve come to appreciate during busy nights or gatherings. It’s a time-saver, allowing me to focus on crafting the drink rather than waiting on the ice.

Crafted for whiskey, cocktail, brandy, and bourbon enthusiasts, these spheres elevate the drinking experience.

There’s something undeniably sophisticated about a glass with a clear ice sphere, and TINANA ensures that this luxury is accessible every time.

However, perfection comes with its challenges. Achieving that crystal clear result requires a bit more attention to the freezing process. While the results are worth it, those new to the clear ice game might need a few tries to nail it down.

In essence, TINANA’s Ice Ball Maker is for those who value the finer things in life. It’s a blend of form and function, ensuring that every drink is not just consumed but truly appreciated.

Pros:

• Produces crystal clear ice spheres.
• The 4-cavity design is perfect for multiple servings.
• Elevates the aesthetic of any drink.

Cons:

• Requires precise freezing for optimal clarity.
• Might have a learning curve for perfect results.

6. Samuelworld Large Silicone Ice Cube Tray Molds

Every great bartender knows that the right ice can transform a drink from ordinary to extraordinary. With Samuelworld’s Large Silicone Ice Cube Tray Molds, that transformation becomes a delightful routine.

First impressions? These molds are all about size and simplicity. Each tray produces big 2-inch cubes, which, in my experience, are perfect for those drinks that deserve a slow, undisturbed chill.

Think of a vintage whiskey or a meticulously crafted cocktail; these cubes ensure that the flavors meld and mature without a rush.

Being silicone, the trays are incredibly user-friendly. I’ve had my fair share of battles with rigid ice molds, but these? A gentle push, and the cubes pop right out.

It’s this ease of use, combined with the cube size, that makes them a favorite, especially during those peak hours behind the bar.

The black hue of the trays adds a touch of sleekness, subtly hinting at their premium nature. And with 8 cavities per tray, there’s plenty of ice to go around, whether it’s a quiet evening or a thumping party.

While I’m all praises for the functionality and design, there’s a tiny caveat. Given the size of the cubes, they do take a bit longer to freeze solidly.

But trust me, the wait is worth it. Every time.

Pros:

• Produces large 2-inch cubes for slow melting.
• Silicone ensures easy ice release.
• Sleek black design with ample cavities.

Cons:

• Requires a slightly longer freezing time.

---

7. WIBIMEN Large Ice Cube Tray

As you’ve likely gathered by now, when it comes to crafting the perfect drink, the ice can be as crucial as the spirit itself.

WIBIMEN’s Large Ice Cube Tray doesn’t just understand this; it elevates it, offering a comprehensive ice solution that’s hard to beat.

Right from the get-go, the 2.5-inch sphere ice mold caught my attention. These sizable spheres are ideal for drinks that deserve a lingering chill, ensuring that every sip is as flavorful as the first.

Whether it’s a robust whiskey or a delicate cocktail, these ice balls ensure minimal dilution while maximizing taste.

But what truly sets this product apart is the thoughtful addition of a bin and tong. No more scrambling for storage or fumbling with hands; the bin ensures that any excess ice has a home, while the tongs make handling a breeze.

It’s these little touches that showcase WIBIMEN’s commitment to a seamless bartending experience.

Crafted in a striking blue hue, these trays aren’t just functional; they’re a visual treat. The silicone material ensures that the ice release is hassle-free, eliminating the all-too-common struggle of extracting the perfect ice sphere.

While the overall design and functionality are great, I did notice that the mold’s seal requires a bit of attention to ensure it’s leak-free.

It’s a minor detail, but worth noting for those aiming for that perfect ice ball every time.

Pros:

• Large 2.5-inch spheres for optimal chilling.
• Comes with a handy bin and tong for storage and handling.
• The vibrant blue design adds a touch of flair.

Cons:

• Seal requires careful attention to prevent leaks.

What To Look For In An Ice Mold

When shopping for an ice mold, especially for bartending purposes, there are several key factors to consider to ensure you get the best quality and functionality for your needs.

Here’s what to look out for when shopping for an ice mold.

Material & Safety

The majority of ice molds are crafted from silicone due to its flexibility and durability.

It’s essential to ensure the silicone is food-grade and BPA-free, guaranteeing that the ice produced is safe for consumption.

Over time, low-quality materials can degrade, affecting the taste and safety of your ice.

>> Read more: 7 BEST Ice Tongs For Bartenders

Size, Shape & Clarity

The aesthetics of your cocktail can be significantly influenced by the size and shape of your ice.

Whether you’re aiming for large, slow-melting cubes for whiskey or intricate designs for themed drinks, the mold should cater to your needs.

Also, molds designed to produce clear ice, free from air bubbles and impurities, can elevate the visual appeal of your drink.

>> Read more: 7 BEST Ice Makers For Home Bars

Ease of Use & Release

A good mold should be user-friendly. It should fill without spilling and produce ice that’s easy to release without a struggle.

The flexibility of the mold’s material plays a crucial role here, ensuring you don’t end up with broken or chipped ice pieces.

Your chosen mold should be robust enough to withstand repeated freezing and potential hot water rinses.

Consider how the mold will fit in your freezer. Stackable designs can be a lifesaver for those with limited space, ensuring you can produce batches without clutter.

>> Read more: 8 BEST Ice Buckets To Keep Beverages Cool

Cleaning & Maintenance

Hygiene is paramount, especially when dealing with consumables. Opt for molds that are straightforward to clean, either by hand or in a dishwasher.

Molds with intricate designs might require more careful cleaning to ensure no residue is left behind.

Value & Recommendations

While it’s tempting to go for the cheapest option, it’s essential to balance cost with quality. Sometimes, a mid-priced mold can offer excellent functionality.

Always check reviews or ask peers for recommendations. Real-world feedback can provide insights into the mold’s longevity, ease of use, and overall performance.

>> Read more: 7 BEST Shot Glasses For Home Bars

FAQs

Final Thoughts

After countless nights behind the bar at work and my own personal home bar, I can tell you this: the details matter.

Ice isn’t just frozen water; it’s an ingredient. Watch your guest’s faces light up as you pull out ice molds to create their Old Fashioned. It’s a game-changer.

The right ice mold can literally transform a good drink into a great one.

So, whether you’re serving up classics or crafting your own concoctions, don’t skimp on the ice.

Trust me, your drinks, and your guests, will thank you for it.

See you next time.